“Citizen journalism site” = splog

I’m not going to link to any offenders, but my consistent observation is that nearly all “citizen journalism” sites fall somewhere between spam blog and crappy community of suckers. If you feel the urge to provide people with a platform to “do” community journalism, don’t. You’re not needed (see below). If you really, really must go ahead, read Evan Prodromou’s seven rules for commercial wikis (which apply to any community site) seven hundred times, then think about it for a long time.

If you feel the need to “do” citizen journalism, stay away from sites that claim they help you “do” citizen journalism. You absolutely do not need them. Instead:

  • Write on your own blog.
  • Write on a site of, by, and for some community (check if they are following the seven rules linked above; it should be obvious).
  • If you want a generic platform, write on .
  • Some reader blogs hosted by established media aren’t that bad, but be careful.
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

2 Responses to ““Citizen journalism site” = splog”

  1. Midas Oracle .ORG » Blog Archive » Citizen Journalism = Crap — Group Blog = Good — Wiki News = Good — Commercial Wikis = Good Says:

    [...] = Crap — Group Blog = Good — Wiki News = Good — Commercial Wikis = Good According to our Mike Linksvayer: I’m not going to link to any offenders, but my consistent observation [*] is that nearly all [...]

  2. Yaron is Writing » Blog Archive » Around the blogs Says:

    [...] Linksvayer says “citizen journalism” sites are a waste of time, given how easy it is to put up one’s own [...]

Leave a Reply